Class 3 vs class 4 climbing deaths reddit Note: These classes are guidelines and not absolutes. 216 votes, 43 comments. I work in roofing and I can tell you that Class 4 is just signing away your insurance company from being liable for cosmetic damage to your roof. I'm currently living away from the mountains and only get to head up when I'm visiting family. I personally think most semi-athletic hikers can handle class 3 without much issue. I’ll also add the step from class 3 to 4, moderate to difficult scrambles is a big one for most, it’s a progression in facing exposure head on. Class 3 Scrambling. I’ve also done some technical climbs up to 5. That route sucked because it was a long slog-fest with a muddy ending. According to the Yosemite Decimal System (YDS), hiking and rock climbing are at two different ends of the same spectrum. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Class 3: Scrambling with increased exposure. All class 4 shingles are sbs based but only Tamko pre oxidizes theirs to prevent it from hardening/becoming brittle after a few years. Jun 22, 2020 · While most of Colorado’s 14ers are an easy hike or scramble, a handful can be quite difficult to climb. Sign In. How much danger I’ve been rock climbing much longer than I’ve been snow climbing and i definitely feel way more confident scrambling exposed class 4/5 rock than moderate snow. Or that even if desired, protection was unavailable. Your hands may be required to stabilize you from time to time, although hiking poles would probably work better. Sport climbing grades are 5. Well traveled and popular 4th class routes tend to be on the easy-side of 4th class. May 5, 2017 · To me, the difference between 3rd class and 4th class is that on 3rd, I may need to use my hands a bit but I could still have both trekking poles out if I wanted, whereas if it's 4th class I'll put the poles away because I'll need my hands too much and there wouldn't be useful places to set the tips against anyway. Tamko titan for class 3, Tamko storm fighter flex for class 4. The home of Climbing on reddit. Finally, class 5 terrain requires five points of contact, the fifth one being a rope. 75-inch diameter steel ball dropped from a height of 17. Class 5 is full-on rock climbing, usually with a rope for protection in case of a fall. A short fall could be possible. Class 4: Simple climbing, with exposure. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Falls could easily be fatal. And the defs are fuzzy so that arguing about a difficulty of 4. Class 5 Technical climbing. Technical rock climbing begins with routes reaching the Class 5 level. What some guides and books call a simple class 3 might be sustained ass-puckering exposure on sketchy terrain. Class 2 Simple scrambling, with the possibility of occasional use of the hands. While 5. Simple climbing, often with exposure. Class 4 shingles are typically considerable jump up. Scrambling Free soloing 5th class at whatever grade is simply an overlap to what most normal climbers are exposed to with sport climbing or single pitch trad. The insurance companies cooked up the class 4 shingle to allow them to not be responsible for any cosmetic damage done to your shingles. The discounts are usually pretty good and they don’t cost an arm and a leg more than the standard 30 year. My favorite climbs are Class 3 and up, with choss. Feb 12, 2019 · Class 4: Class 4 hiking is essentially Class 3 but in a more vertical setting. Apr 26, 2025 · Choosing the right roof shingles is essential for homeowners. I'm comfortable with class 3-4 stuff, but my partner is not and I need some more experience to lead people up more difficult scrambles. Class 3. OH! Or up in the cascades it's what we call a 'Fred Becky class 3'. May 3, 2025 · Welcome to the forum where you'll find loads of 14er topics and more I’ve aged out of free-soloing (mid-30s), but I did it quite a bit through my 20s. 10a or so in difficulty. Si and the Haystack (less than 2 miles in 934M (3034 ft) vs. With steep Class 3 and 4 climbing, dramatic exposure to cliffs and drop-offs, and complex route-finding and navigation, these nine peaks are some of the most difficult Colorado 14ers. If you are wanting to move from class 1 and class 2 alpine hikes, like those found on many 14ers, and move on to class 3 and class 4 climbing, you may need t The ratings are categorized from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 being the highest rating. Old school routes, bolts, anchors and practices. But if the same example might 1-2 tap a Class 3, but 2-3 or even 3-4 tap a Class 4, then I'm interested Thanks! P. Typically, if you are climbing with an inexperienced person, you might provide a rope for THEM on class 4 and coach them and watch them carefully on class 3. Understand the factors influencing your The class 5 portion of the class scale is primarily a rock climbing classification system, while classes 1–4 are used for hiking and scrambling. Class 4 It is steeper yet, exposed and most people use a rope due to the potential of long falls. Very few people catastrophically mistie their knot, fail to attach their rappel device properly, rap off their rope, etc, but if they do while 50+ft off they deck, they die. This ain't "easy climbing" and it's not exposed, that's Class 4; again MFotH: Class 4. Any of the routes listed would be good to get some experience on class 3. 4 climbing here IMO its mostly C4/5), there's a lot of ground to cover and it's easy to get careless for a moment in high-consequence terrain. The chances of death in f1 never goes away but is vanishingly small now. Some class 2 trails I’ve hiked had fixed lines with huge exposure where taking a tumble would’ve been death. [1] The current definition for each class is: [1] Class 1 Hiking or running on a trail. Rock climbing is Class 5. Jan 28, 2022 · As climbing difficulty progresses into Class 4, most people use ropes and protection due to steepness and exposure. Also, the hail that will crush a 3 will most likely crush a 4. A rope Jun 22, 2017 · Class 6. That's rock scrambling, which I'd call climbing because it needs use of hands. 9 vs 5. Three different accidents, one when I’d been climbing for about 3 years, one for about 4, and the last recently. Jun 18, 2003 · Remember me Not recommended on shared computers. It was a completely avoidable accident (the climber was on the top of a frozen waterfall, setting up an anchor, and slipped. The roof is 15 years old (class 3 shingles) and has withstood multiple hail storms. Or that using a rope could actually make the climbing more dangerous (limited pro, more ways to cause rockfall). If this route was class 4, or class 3, the consequences for failure would still be the same. Hiking Boots highly recommended. Class 4: Advanced Climbing. You can have class 3 scrambles in which a major fall would probably end up with just a bruised ego. 1 is not much harder than 4th class. 1. Due to the shortage in shingles I’m very tempted to go with a My roof was destroyed this summer from a hail storm. There is no climbing like free solo. It is not for a Sep 11, 2015 · A nice chart by Mountain Madness explaining the intricacies of Class 5 climbing may be found at this link. Ice and rock fall on an alpine route, another was a slip and long fall on a low grade section of an alpine route, and last was a freak accident with a loose boulder on a class 3 section of a trad route. You can have class 1 hikes with serious exposure. The area is known for low angle slab climbing. Class 3: Sustained hands-on scrambling, with decent exposure; Class 4: Difficult scrambling in no-fall territory; Class 5: Technical rock climbing. Two ice axes will probably be needed. Due to the fact that this form of climbing would certainly result in death in the event of a fall, certain specific gear is used to prevent injury. The truth is class 3 and class 4 is a lot more subjective. NZ 4: Technical climbing. And if you want to slum a bit, Mt Adams c2c is about 13 hours round trip, from camp at 5,555 to summit at 12,276', by the South Spur route. If you are seriously out there in the mountains or outback you have done plenty of scrambling, down climbing, traverses etc that a typical local sport kid would say is insane solo climbing. 235 votes, 57 comments. Class 1. This is a problem throughout the Elks, and it requires a high level of caution on the class four sections or technical routes. It might be 90 feet of 5. A fall could be fatal. The central Sierra - South of the Minerates to Mount Tom are known for being some of the most rotten scree climbs in the lower 48. There would be many large handholds, and while you probably wouldn't fall on Class-4, a fall none-the-less would be long and would result in great injury or death. Unfortunately, the consequences for failure are the same. Class 1 is what we call hiking, simply walking along a trail. 9 feet without showing signs of damage like cracks or punctures. Jul 21, 2023 · Scrambling vs. The last 1000’ is continuous tough Class 3 and Class 4 climbing. Class 3 Climbing a steep hillside, moderate exposure, a rope may be carried but not used, and hands are used in climbing. What is it? Class 1 scrambling is essentially a steep walk. Unroped climbers risk severe injury or fatality in the event of a fall. 7 face climbing with the top out being (a fucking hike) 30 feet of literal class 3 walking. Nothing too technical but there are some pretty large crevasses so just be surefooted. Climbing. Lots of climbs share a common anchor that really shouldn’t. NZ 2: A class 3-4 scramble with snow and ice mixed in. The only reason I'd suggest it as a first class 3 is because it's only fun when it's a novel experience (and its overhyped/technically easier than Kelso). I’m a fan of going with Class 3. A rope is And if you like a bit of spice, Mt Shuksan via the Sulphide glacier, and it has a Class 4 800' rock pyramid on top ;). Whereas on obscure 4th class routes it is normal to encounter short sections of easy 5th class terrain. Learn about Class 3 and Class 4 shingles, their impact resistance, and how selecting Class 4 shingles can lead to insurance savings. Class 4 is when a novice won't recognize some of the required holds. GAF is trash, Malarkey is trash, OC and Certainteed are good. Climbing single/double pitch routes up to 5. 0 may be pointless From Freedom of the Hills (7th ed): * Class 1: Hiking * Class 2: Simple scrambing, with possible occasional use of the hands * Class 3: Scrambing; a rope might be carried * Class 4: Simple climbing, often with exposure. Class 3 vs Class 4 shingle . Finally, let’s Nov 29, 2023 · For those looking to progress beyond Class 3 climbing, the next level of challenge awaits with Class 4: Advanced Climbing. while all other websites and resources were saying if you live in a climate where severe weather is possible, class 4 may be worth it. Class 4 terrain is where mountaineering begins to enter the realm of technical climbing. There is much gray area May 7, 2020 · In climbing, most experienced climbers will never rope up on class 3 and only very rarely on class 4. If your confident on class 3, you absolutely can progress into class 4, first look for routes with “short” sections of difficult scrambling and as your comfort level rises progress to harder routes. May 29, 2023 · West Dog Teeth and Lantau Peak together is twice as steep as Mt. 4 miles in 3100 ft). The roofing contractor is pushing class 4 shingles pretty hard but I am reading conflicting reviews online with some stating their insurance company declined claims yet required the homeowner to replace damaged shingles. This is called the Yosemite Decimal System (YDS). 4 is easy for any decent climber (and there's only a few sections of true 5. Good placement of rock protection and ice screws is required; NZ 5: Sustained technical climbing with ice up to WI 4/5 We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I know that in certain conditions snow travel can be more secure and efficient than rock but I’ve yet to conquer the mental game of snow climbing. S. Jul 15, 2006 · They may also vary by region or group. . Class 3 means you have to use your hands to help you progress. The sport is not safe and does not tolerate failure well. Little potential danger is encountered. Oct 15, 2018 · 5. Class 4 hikes involve the use of hands and feet on a surface where a fall would result in a serious injury or death. F1 is a good example which uses all deaths since 1950 to extrapolate probability of future deaths. Scrambling; hands are used for balance; a rope might be carried. When I had a roofer out for an estimate, the additional cost to upgrade to Class 4 was not much at all, so I was debating. For example, on the route in The sawtooth between Bierstadt and Evans was my first class 3. Note: In the 1950s, the Class 5 portion of this ranking system was expanded to include a decimal at the end of the ranking to further define the difficulties of rock climbing. Advanced climbing skills, equipment, and experience are necessary to navigate this challenging rating. Class 3 Shingles : These shingles are designed to withstand the impact of a 1. Aasgard is solidly class 2, could even be class 1 if you had really good balance. It is not for a The big difference in roped climbing vs MTB is that death is almost always a potential consequence of certain mistakes, even if you only top rope. And yes we are scared of falling. The hikers' subreddit. 4 rating doesn't really encapsulate the difficulty. Dec 29, 2019 · Class 3 Climbing a steep hillside, moderate exposure, a rope may be carried but not used, and hands are used in climbing. You’ll often hear a person say “That’s an easy Class 4 climb. X as they are class 5 terrain! Bouldering Grades. NZ 3: Longer, more sustained climbing, with technical tools required. Forgot your password? Sign Up Jan 13, 2020 · Class 5: Free Climbing (Free from Aid) – This technical climbing class involves using your own physical power (hands and feet) to ascend a route or rock face from bottom to top. Which if you know anything at all about f1 you know that's simply idiotic. If you're unfamiliar with the general route, there are essentially 3 parts to Huntington: When you first spill out into the cirque, you're in the boulder field, climbing up over, under, around rocks up to the size of houses. On Boulder’s Third Flatiron. In just under 4 miles you’ll get to gain 4550’ in elevation, so be prepared for some serious climbing! The geology falls into the crumbling, sedimentary category. Any suggestions on how to gather more necessary preparations whether that comes from climbing gyms, certain classes, or non-negotiable gear? Jun 18, 2003 · Class 4 can include both simul climbing and pitches which are belayed but on which pro is not placed (leader solos dragging rope for benefit of second) as well as pitches which are 3rd classed but which the scrambler feels are more difficult than class 3 and should be noted as such. You fall off the wrong class 3, not even a 4, and you’re just dead. 0 and 5. So far, a novice can recognize the holds and they're plentiful. 2M subscribers in the hiking community. The route from the trailhead to the 12,800’ saddle is relentlessly steep. ” or “That’s a hard class two+ scramble” or similar. The climbing involves the use of rope and belaying. Exposure is something entirely separate. 1, toxic substances, is used to classify substances that - in relatively small amounts and in a short duration - can cause serious injury or death to humans if swallowed, inhaled or with by absorption through skin contact. It is not uncommon to encounter moves of easy 5th class on a hard 4th class scramble. A good example of a harder scramble, a class 3 multipitch slab, is Huntington's Ravine Tr, Mt Washington. Like many classics, the 5. There are, as usual, lot of deaths in there from scrambling, un-roped approaches on class 4 or easy class 5 terrain I'm only a beginner climber myself but several years ago I knew a guy who died because he tripped on a climber's trail just getting to where the "real" climb was going to be. May 2, 2023 · In class 4, both feet plus both hands or other points of contact (two feet + two hands = class four) are required for more exposed scrambling and simple climbing. A rope is often used. I’m not sure of the routes names. For example, if the most common ammos of a level 30+ player right now are going to 1-2 tap a Class 3, and 2 tap a Class 4, I don't think it matters that much. Class 1 is easy trails, class 2 is difficult trail or no trail, class 3 is scrambling, class 4 is very steep scrambling/easy climbing, class 5 is full rock climbing. F1 cars were absolute death traps until the 80s/90s and are now mind bendingly safe. Class 4 is where you really need to be careful with loose rock and testing your holds. You underestimate the risk of ordinary, everyday scrambles. For instance: Class 4: Hands, long fall, maybe ropes. Very beautiful back country. This guide explores different shingle materials including asphalt, wood, metal, and slate, highlighting their advantages, lifespan, and weather resistance. 2/3, and basic bouldering in a gym, so I have a beginner’s knowledge of how to move, keeping three points of contact, and problem-solving. I 100% understand the allure and freedom, it’s honestly the hardest adrenaline rush you can get climbing. Class 5 Climbing is technical and belayed roping with protection is required. I wasn’t there for any of I can confidently take on class 3 scrambling and but it sounds like this particular class 4 carries a wider range of required capability if I want to do it safely. Class-4 is easy climbing over steep, exposed terrain where you need your hands. The class rating is somewhat subjective and the boundaries between classes can be a bit fuzzy, but this is a general overview. A rope should be available for learning climbers, or if you just choose to use one that day, but is usually not required. 3M subscribers in the climbing community. Handholds are necessary. I also would recommend you are comfortable with exposure before moving on to class 4. Scrambling is smack dab in the middle. There have also been deaths through the years on the knife's edge (although I don't believe any this year), which is probably mostly from people panicking due to the visual and stumbling. Reply reply Hey Guys, In case some of you aren't aware of the original story (Click here for the OP), I lost a friend in a climbing accident about a month ago. gsrljg xto qlc qslggt ybxp zorecx hlk egfd sjn yoble